Mike Parker: ‘Trying Times’ in November 1776
Less than six months after the Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence, the hope of the united colonies to achieve independence from Great Britain seemed to be waning fast.
November 1776 did little to rebuild the hope of winning liberty. On November 16, 1776, on the island of Manhattan, the Battle of Fort Washington marked the final, devastating chapter of General Washington’s disastrous New York Campaign.
After winning a major victory on Long Island in August, British General William Howe began to move against New York City in mid-September. Gen. George Washington was unwilling to abandon Manhattan entirely, so he ordered Gen. Nathanael Greene to defend the stronghold.
Built in June of 1776, Forts Washington and Lee guarded the Hudson River from British warships. Though hastily constructed, Fort Washington wrought havoc on British warships attempting to sail up the Hudson River. On October 27, two British frigates suffered heavy damage from the forts as the ships supported probing attacks on the Fort Washington defenses. The ships, whose guns could not elevate high enough to attack the forts, were saved only after being towed out of the line of fire.
Forts Washington and Lee similarly repulsed Hessian attacks in early November. These early successes gave Gen. Greene and Col. Robert Magaw, the fort’s garrison commander, a false sense of security.
When the British received intelligence that Gen. Washington had divided his Continental forces, Gen. William Howe and Hessian Gen. Wilhelm von Knyphausen attacked the fort with more than 8,000 British and Hessian troops. Their goal: Gain control over the Hudson River. Fort Washington had approximately 3,000 Americans.
After a long and difficult battle, the British and Hessians surrounded the fort and forced its surrender. The British and Hessians suffered greater combat losses than the Americans, with approximately 86 killed and more than 350 wounded, compared to 59 Americans killed and just over 100 wounded.
The rest of the 2,837 American soldiers were marched out of the fort by Hessian soldiers and forced into captivity. As the winter months approached, the American soldiers were crammed into unheated barns, sheds, and onto British prison ships. Hundreds of prisoners from Fort Washington died of disease and physical hardship.
The quick action at Fort Lee, although not truly decisive, marked a new period for the American army. The capture and retreat from Fort Lee started the brutal march through New Jersey. Through extraordinary leadership, the army survived and fought decisively one month later at Trenton and Princeton.
Four days later, British General Charles Lord Cornwallis and his Hessian counterpart, Col. Carl von Donop, landed 5,000 troops at the base of the New Jersey Palisades to attack Fort Lee. Fort Lee had an unsupported force of 2,000 men. Washington and his top generals, who had narrowly escaped Fort Washington, decided to evacuate Fort Lee rather than risk more losses.
This withdrawal began the long retreat across New Jersey, ending with Washington and his army clinging to survival on the Pennsylvania side of the Delaware River as Christmas 1776 approached.
As Fort Lee was being evacuated, Thomas Paine wrote the first essay in The American Crisis series. Paine had been with the American soldiers as they evacuated Fort Lee and began their trek to Pennsylvania. He experienced firsthand the hardships the soldiers endured. He saw their dimming hopes.
The opening words for Crisis No. 1 are immortal: “These are the times that try men’s souls.”
After offering scathing criticism of “the summer soldier and the sunshine patriot,” Paine observed: “What we obtain too cheap, we esteem too lightly.” His words encouraged Patriots, both those serving on the battlefields and citizens who supported the revolution, to gain independence.
Mike Parker is a columnist for the Neuse News. You can reach him at mparker16@gmail.com.



